Wednesday, January 22, 2003

Bush’s policy hampers situation

The present crisis in the Korean Peninsula reveals the flaws of the Bush administration’s “axis of evil” policy. By lumping together highly desperate nations (North Korea, Iraq and Iran), Washington is hampered in its ability to come up with delicate and different responses that are required in dealing with each nation.

The dual doctrines of “pre-emptive strike” combined with the “axis of evil” policy sent shock waves of insecurity and fear into the already paranoid leaders of North Korea. Having witnessed one “axis of evil” country targeted for attack and regime change (Iraq), the Communist regime in North Korea fear they are next. The tough talk of the Bush administration has forced Pyongyang to play its nuclear card.

The rapprochement between North and South Korea, painstakingly shepherded by the Clinton administration is now derailed and the tensions in the Korean Peninsula have escalated considerably. North Korea has resumed its nuclear program and has expelled the international inspectors from the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA). North Korea has also withdrawn from the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty, and threatens to restart ballistic missile testing. Realizing the present preoccupation of the Bush administration with Iraq, North Korean leaders see this as an opportune time to escalate the crisis.

U.S. regional allies, especially South Korea and China, favor engagement rather than confrontation with North Korea. The support for unity with the North is particularly strong and there have been numerous anti-American demonstrations recently. Many South Koreans are also demanding the departure of some 37,000 American troops stationed there. If the tensions between the United States and North Korea escalate, and South Korea is pushed to take sides with the North, it could affect the extensive trade and diplomatic relations between the two countries.

Perhaps, partially due to pressure of allies, President Bush signaled a sharp turn from the policy of no deal with North Korea, when he announced Jan. 14 that North Korea could expect to receive food and energy aid if it relinquishes its nuclear energy program. But North Korea has called the new offer a deceptive ploy.

The Bush administration faces a dilemma. If they come across as too conciliatory, they risk having rewarded belligerence. If they take a tough stand, they risk the deterioration of their relationship with South Korea and China.

Driven by its dire poverty, North Korea has an active program of missile sales to several third world countries. If the North Korean nuclear program is not shut down, its nuclear weapons could end up in the wrong hands, including terrorist groups.

 

Manochehr Dorraj is a professor of political science.
He can be reached at (m.dorraj@tcu.edu).


credits

TCU Daily Skiff © 2003