TCU Daily Skiff Masthead
Thursday, April 3, 2003
news campus opinion sports features

Point/Counterpoint
The Issue: Does affirmative action lead to more diverse college and university campuses?
Affirmative action needed to ensure diversity

Race should not be a factor for admissions

Sometimes I wonder if I will ever live in a world where race is not an issue. It seems no matter whom I am with, at some time the discussion will turn to race. Although in most of these conversations the talk is educational rather than negative and derogatory, I wonder still if there ever will be a day when I do not think about what color the person is sitting next to me.

Students on campuses around the country may soon be considering the issue of race more after the Supreme Court hands down a decision in a controversial case this summer. The court heard arguments this week about whether the University of Michigan’s consideration of race in admissions is constitutional. Specifically, the court is considering the case of a student who was not admitted, in her opinion, because she is white.

The University of Michigan swears it does not use racial quotas, but instead considers race as one of the many factors in deciding admission, along with other factors such as a student’s GPA and extracurricular activities.

Critics of this method and the staunchest supporters of a Supreme Court decision against it say colleges should not use race as a factor and schools should only use race-neutral techniques. This case is gearing up to be one of the most important cases in affirmative action in a while, and many of the country’s leaders are speaking up.

The White House issued a statement saying it opposed factoring race in university admission policies and labeled Michigan’s policies as an almost-but-not-quite quota system. Secretary of State Colin Powell issued his own statements saying racial considerations had to be made because the country was not “race neutral” yet, according to CNN.

Powell has a point. The country is not yet race neutral, and there are many students who deserve to be afforded every chance as everyone else is. Because this country is not race neutral yet, we must actively seek out and make diversified environments.

According to Louisiana State University’s campus newspaper archive, LSU’s admissions policies are different from Michigan’s. LSU insists it considers applicants based on the usual factors of grades and personal accomplishments.

Although I agree with Powell that to achieve diversity, race should be considered, the best way to achieve this diversity is not through screening applicants on the basis of race, even if it is only one of the factors.

Instead of considering the races of applicants in the applicant pool, LSU works at actively recruiting more minority students. If you want a more diverse school (or workplace, or whatever), you just make the pool of people you want bigger. That way you don’t have to consider their race at all, you simply pick the most qualified people.

Along with specifically targeting recruitment efforts toward minorities, aiming incentives such as scholarships at minority groups automatically will bring in more diverse students. Having programs that encourage diversity, but also cultural education, will make the university more attractive to diverse students.

According to a Reveille article, LSU’s office of Undergraduate Admissions now has a “Cultural Connection” program that will give minority groups special attention. These sorts of ideas will bring more quality minority students to apply, and then race won’t have to be considered.

So, although I agree with leaders such as Powell that we are not race neutral and because of this we have to purposely work to encourage diversity, I do not agree considering race in admissions is the best way. Let’s try other ways first.

That way, when someone does get accepted to college, there will be no doubt in his or her mind they got in because they are the kind of student the university wants to have — not because they happen to be a minority and the university needs more of them.

Adrienne Breaux is a columnist for The Reveille at Louisiana State University. This column was distributed by U-Wire.

 

 

credits
TCU Daily Skiff © 2003

skiffTV image magazine advertising jobs back issues search

Accessibility