Friday, November 30, 2001

Garth Brooks comes back to country on ‘Scarecrows’
By Julie Ann Matonis
Skiff Staff

Garth Brooks is trying to reclaim an old cowboy hat.

This week, “Scarecrow,” Brooks’ ninth album excluding special compilations and holiday albums, sits atop the music charts. The album is Brooks’ latest material since his 1999 pop music flop, “The Life of Chris Gaines.” It seems Brooks has learned his lesson. Stick with what you do best: country.

Brooks, who has won every major award and sold more than 100 million albums, said the name of the album came from his three daughters, who reminded him that the scarecrow from “The Wizard of Oz” thought with his heart. The album contains 12 new songs including “When You Come Back to Me Again,” the theme from the movie, “Frequency.” Brooks also duets with Trisha Yearwood and country music legend George Jones.

“Scarecrow” may sell millions because even though it does not live up to previous albums, fans will jump for new music from Brooks.

Listening to “Scarecrow” is like putting on a faded sweatshirt. It is comfortable but not flashy. It sounds similar to Brooks’ early albums, but there is no standout effort destined to be another “Friends in Low Places” or “The Dance.” The greatest achievement is that Brooks’ voice carries the music without sounding too produced. Acoustic guitar, piano and fiddle are more than enough to accompany him.

The upbeat songs, like “Beer Run” and “Squeeze Me In,” will grab the listener’s attention, but the lyrics won’t linger. The ballads, “The Storm” and “Mr. Midnight,” slow the pace of the album to a crawl. The exception is the ballad, “Pushing Up Daisies,” which appears to be a tribute to Brooks’ mother who died last year. Brooks has publicly said he will not tour to support “Scarecrow,” which he also has said will be his last album. However, fans will see Brooks in the coming months as the new spokesman for Dr. Pepper and in three live CBS concerts.

All that can really be said about “Scarecrow” is that it sounds like Garth Brooks. Die-hard fans will be relieved.

Welcome back. Sort of..

— Julie Ann Matonis